One more time, people: Israel is a country, Judaism is a religion. Criticism of the Israeli government is not criticism of Jews or Jewishness (”anti-Semitism”).
One of the founding principles of my country, the United States, is called ’separation of church and state’. The idea is to allow citizens to freely practice (or not) the religion of their choice, separate from the affairs of government. While breaches do occur, allowing Christians Jews Buddhists and Muslims to coexist with themselves, native Americans and atheists is, I think, a good thing.
Israel illustrates some of the dangers of state-sponsored religion. As if patriotism and missionary zeal aren’t bad enough apart, combining them leads to the exact charge reported now in David Landau’s Sunday Times column, that by criticizing Israel’s invasion of Gaza, the United Nations’ report on that activity is anti-Semitic.
One more time, people: Israel is a country, Judaism is a religion.
Wondering if these days we could use a government principle of ’separation of corporation and state’. Rather too late for my country, I’m afraid. But I digress.
By granting practitioners of one religion (Judaism in this case) more legal rights than others, you explicitly create a society consisting of a privileged group and an underclass. This is a mistake made by many countries, including my own, which we are still undoing damage from.
The United States’ founders had the good sense to grant equality to different religions, but created privileged and non-privileged groups by allowing slavery. That practice flourished for a hundred years, and it took a civil war to abolish, and another hundred years to grant legal parity to non-whites in this country.
But we’re working on it in this country. Israel, founded on the principle of one religion being superior, is not and cannot. And underclasses typically feel exasperated and oppressed.